Broadhead

Top 9 Best Broadheads for Deer in 2017

4When hunting deer you may be shooting from a blind or a tree stand and that’s going to make a difference in your shot. The thing is that you still need to be able to get good penetration no matter what your style and many hunters will tell you that there’s plenty of reasons why you should consider both fixed and expandables when looking for the best broadheads for deer.

A lot of the time if you’re ground hunting you want to have something that’s going to bleed out from a nice low wound which is why an expandable (which has a bigger cutting diameter) can be a better choice. But what about hybrids? A cut on contact expandable is a good compromise if you’re not sure whether you prefer fixed or not. However, when taking an angled shot if you’re not perfectly on with a fixed blade you might not get the kill because the broadhead isn’t causing enough damage, something you won’t have to worry about with a mechanical head.

The best deer broadhead is one that works with your style and many people flatly refuse to budge from fixed blade broadheads even when their rate could be improved by adding mechanicals in certain situations. Fixed broadheads are indeed more reliable but they’re not as good when it comes to the size of the wound or when taking quartering shots.

An expandable broadhead guarantees a larger wound channel and you can look at any number of deer broadhead reviews and see the same thing.

Click here for the Best Broadheads for Deer available in 2017!

The Top 9 Best Broadheads for Deer

Here are the topic choices when it come to broadbands for deer.

Trophy Ridge Meat Seeker 3 Blade Rocket Aerohead – $XX.XX / 3

Trophy Ridge Meat Seeker 3 Blade Rocket Aerohead

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars from 21 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

With a unique twisted chisel-tip these take the same concept as the Grim Reapers but make it better.

This twisted design helps the head to slide around bone where there’s less resistance which in turn gives maximum penetration.

This head is also unique in that the nose is spring loaded like a pressure plate so as that tip impresses on contact it causes the blades to release.

This comes in two sizes and if you’re going for the 2” then you’ll be looking at a sizable wound channel and quick take down no matter how big the deer.

  • 1 1/2- 2” Cutting diameter
  • 100, 125 grain
  • Penetration Unknown

Pros:

The clever tip design is incredibly useful for smashing through bone without damaging the heads, and despite the delicate look of the blades they inflict maximum damage with a blood trail that a blind man could follow. The blades stay closed even when shot with a powerful bow thanks to that rubber band so you never have to worry about levers or such failing at crucial moment since there’s never a doubt that those blades can cut when triggered.

Cons:

These will stick in your quiver and have to be stored with the rubber band so that they stay closed, which can mean you’re likely to get cut replacing it. If that’s not a problem then you’ll also probably need to choose a heavier or lighter band depending on your bow if you want decent accuracy. You’ll also want to tighten down the screws before using these as they often arrive a little loose.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

Swhacker 100 Grain 1.75 Inch Cut Broadheads – $XX.XX / 3

Set of 3 Swhacker 100 Grain 1.75 Inch Cut Broadheads

Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars from 28 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

These are pretty ugly looking but they’re aimed at being rugged and sturdy which is why the build is so “heavy”.

The design uses a shrink collar to keep the blades tight during flight which hugs the ferrule and prevents the blades causing drag by premature deployment.

The blades are also set far back on the ferrule so that jack-knifed and quartered shots are more likely to do enough damage to kill even if not on target since the blades will open as the head spins and still penetrate.

Holding the moment of deployment until after contact helps to keep the arrow traveling faster so it can go straight through and cause  damage at a more critical time – internally.

  • 100 grain
  • 7 1/16” penetration
  • 1 3/4” cutting diameter
  • Practice Head Included

Pros:

The clever design of these short little blades means that the second set only opens after penetration, leaving virgin sharp edges free to cut internally and at the exit point for a cleaner wound channel. This also helps create more internal damage so the animal bleeds out faster for a quicker and more humane kill. Because the small blades do not make a lot of aerodynamic difference from field points these are really accurate and easy to shoot with the same proficiency.

Cons:

These come with a great practice head that is practically identical, something bad if you were to accidentally use it out hunting. To prevent this you’ll need to mark it somehow. The design also means that while the arrow will fly faster to the target, when the head hits, it will slow down considerably and this means that you’re less likely to get a through shot because of the energy transfer in releasing those blades.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

Grim Reaper Whitetail Special- $XX.XX /3

Grim Reaper Razorcut SS Expandable Broadhead 3-Pack

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars from 66 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

These are one of the most popular mechanical broadheads and it’s got a lot to do with the rather wicked looking blades.

This has a similar collar design to that of the Shwacker so that you won’t get pre-deployment but it also has a chisel-tip so that helps drive the broadhead in smoother than the Shwacker tip.

Having that chisel tip will also help to protect the exposed blades in the case of a bad hit by shattering any bone in the way first.

The entire thing is rather large but that means it’s got an impressive cutting diameter to match.

The blades hug the ferrule in a way that means these are only suitable for faster bows (and you can tell the difference).

  • 100 grain
  • 2” cutting diameter
  • 6 7/8” penetration
  • Practice Head Included

Pros:

The extra long ferrule on this broadhead design slices quickly through hide and bone with set back blades similar to that of the Schwacker . This means it can cause more internal damage since they’re deployed after penetrating faster. The large cutting diameter leaves impressive and easy to follow blood trails but closes back up as it’s exiting so that it can be handled. This can mean that people mistakenly think that the blades failed to deploy at all. This level of internal damage also means that the deer will drop quicker for a more humane kill.

Cons:

There’s a problem with sub-par fakes so it’s important to be careful where you source these. The poor quality steel will shatter most of the time and have poorer penetration than the real deal. While the designers hope you assume that the blades really have closed back up after a through shot there are plenty of instances where hunters have seen them fail to deploy. This means that there’s a problem with the spring system and a risk for lost kills and wasted heads.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

Rage Xtreme – $XX.XX / 3

Rage X-treme Two Blade Broadhead

Rated 4.1 out of 5 stars from 101 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

These broadheads have the largest cutting diameter available, which means they are designed to do serious damage.

The blades are huge but could be a little sharper. The design is different from most other broadheads in that the blades are rear deploying.

This gives them a better aerodynamic angle upon entry and helps to maintain the speed of the arrow longer so there’s more chance of a through shot.

This means better initial penetration and more internal damage to the animal since the blades will be virgin clean after penetration.

This has a dual blade design like the Shwecker but also has a chiseled head like the Whitetail special.

  • 2 1/4” Cutting diameter
  • 100 Grain
  • 8” Penetration
  • Practice Head Included

Pros:

These broadheads are designed for bows with higher draw weights. Rage is a very well known and popular brand because their broadheads are the most dependable. The Rage design has been updated several times since it’s inception to deal with a collar failure issue. The performance remains fairly consistent and now that there’s no o-rings they’re also easier to use. The blade design leads to massive blood loss quickly so that they have to be considered as one of the most ethical choices of broadheads. As the cutting diameter is so large it also delivers lethal performance no matter how big your prey.

Cons:

The build of these broadheads is not very sturdy which means it’s possible that you can damage the collar and shatter the head with a wrongly placed shot. The blades just aren’t very sharp which means for someone who really wants that extra mile you’ll also have to sharpen them before use. These broadheads are also just standard steel, there’s no hardening process used which means the sharpening process can be a headache and may not make much of a difference. There’s also a likelihood that the blades will shatter upon entry and you won’t be able to find them inside your kill. Probably the biggest issue with the Rage is going to be the large profile, this means you’ll get a chance of deflection when shooting from an angle.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

Kill Switch Dead 150 Grain Hunting Broadhead Arrowhead – $XX.XX / 3

Kill Switch Dead 150 Grain Turkey Hunting Broadhead Arrowhead

Rated 3.0 out of 5 stars from 7 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

You’re probably wondering why a 150 grain is here but if you’re out in the Midwest you know that mule deer can be tougher since you’ve got to have something that flies over a long flat range and punch through hard enough to get the job done.

The Kill Switch is better for traditional archers with a punchy 150 grain head and an ultra low profile that travels silently.

The huge 5” razors is going to be overkill for the average white tail but these will definitely cause a lot of internal damage even at larger distances because of that.

  • 150 grain
  • 5” cutting diameter
  • Penetration Unavailable
  • Practice Head Included

Pros:

With a devastating cutting zone this is designed to be tough with two stainless blades and a strong ferrule that punches right through bone and hide without any difficulty. The tiny profile of this means the broadhead flies exactly like a field tip and will have the same impressive accuracy.

Cons:

There’s a good chance that the blades will shatter on the wrong shot because of the sheer width. While the damage is going to be substantial these should really only be used on particular circumstances (like mule deer on long range) because of this. There’s also the issue of just how heavy these are, at 150 grains they’re pretty much overkill.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

New Archery Products Killzone – $XX.XX / 3

NEW ARCHERY PRODUCTS KILLZONE 100GR 3PK

Rated 4.1 out of 5 stars from 25 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

New Archery Products are known as a very dependable brand; plus they have some grand products.

So good in fact that there’s two here – the Killzone and the Bloodrunner.

When compared together the Bloodrunner wins but the Killzone itself is still worthy of mention.

This is because the Killzone actually offers three different tips – trophy tip, cut on contact and deep six.

The trophy tips are designed for shattering bone while the deep 6 have a shaft that fits directly into NAPs deep 6 arrows.

The construction of these broadheads is strong and they have ultra sharp blades no matter which head you choose.

  • 2” cutting diameter
  • 100 Grain
  • 3 tip models
  • 5 1/4” Penetration
  • Practice Blades may/may not be included

Pros:

The Killzone leaves a nice big wound  channel no matter which tip you choose thanks to those sharp blades. The option for three different tips is convenient and allows the same heads to work for multiple different styles of hunter. These feature a collared design to prevent early deployment which is very well done and there’s practically no examples of them deploying early unlike the White Tail Special which may not deploy at all. The impressive size of the entry and exit wounds mean that your deer drops quickly, comparable to the Grim Reaper broadheads since the blade diameter is about the same.

Cons:

The biggest issue that NAP has is consistency since the variance in weight with each head can be as much as 9.9g, a considerable amount. The penetration is also a poorer than most others in this category and changing the blades is a pain. There isn’t always a practice set included is also annoying as this depends on your supplier. In fact, if you do get a practice set you’re not even changing the entire head, just the blades so you may end up damaging the head while practicing. There are also noted consistencies in the spring tension from pack to pack, making them unreliable and you won’t have the same result each time because of the difference in springs.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

New Archery Products Bloodrunner 2 – $XX.XX /3

New Archery Products 100 Grain Broadhead 3 Per Pack 3 Blade Bloodrunner

Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars from 20 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

The Bloodrunner is the sister-product to the Killzone and they’re similar but the Bloodrunner is definitely the upgraded tech.

This is called a hybrid design broadhead because it’s got  the low profile of a fixed head for great accuracy but still has secondary blades that expand upon contact with the target.

This combination gives you the best of both worlds so that you will definitely get a wide enough wound channel to kill even if the blades fail to deploy.

Check your state laws however, as the combination design means that these are considered barbed broadheads which are illegal in some states.

  • Penetration Unknown
  • 100 Grain
  • 2 1/6” cutting diameter

Pros:

These leave a large diameter hole for a good blood trail even if they’re not field point accurate. The hybrid concept is a very cleaver idea because it gives you more reliability like a fixed blade but the added wider wound channel of an expanding broadhead. This is means that when it really counts it negates that worry that a mechanical head may fail by still giving you enough diameter to kill without it deploying.

Cons:

There’s no practice head which means that since the accuracy is questionable you’ll probably need to sacrifice a head to get this adjusted right. This is also fairly hard to clean if you want to reuse them which can be a problem. The mechanical areas  are especially difficult which can make them sticky which will prevent them deploying properly. The biggest problem however is a very slight rattle upon deployment which really puts the hybrid at a disadvantage with both types if it spooks the deer which may put your shot off target.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

Fixed-blade Broadheads

If you’re shooting from a lower angle or at ground level then a fixed blade is probably going to be a better choice simply because you need simple power and speed. That’s not saying you can’t use a mechanical to take a deer down on the flat but you’ll want the reliability that a fixed blade can offer.

Muzzy Trocar – $XX.XX / 3

Muzzy Broadheads New Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3 Blade with Offset Blade Design (3-Pack)

Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars from 42 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

Muzzy is rather the “old faithful” of broadheads.

Many hunters grew up using a Muzzy thanks to names like Tom Miranda and even the newest models are reliable with the Muzzy name behind it.

The helix blade design gives the broadhead real stability during flight then a good sized wound at the end even when used at longer ranges.

They’re close to field point perfect because they’re fixed instead of expandable and will leave a nice blood trail when shot right.

  • 100 grain
  • 1 3/16” max cutting diameter
  • Penetration Unavailable

Pros:

This has a combination design so that there are multiple cutting edges but the chisel tip can easily shatter bone so you won’t have to worry as much about the reliability compared to using a mechanical. The heads are also very small so they add little weight which may be a concern if you’re looking for a larger wound channel but they still give a good sized cutting diameter that’s sufficient to kill. The one piece construction means that there’s no fuss and nothing to take apart.

Cons:

The blades are sharp, but they could be sharper, especially compared to some of the mechanicals. You may want to sharpen them before trying to put them to use in the field even if they’re new. It’s also almost imperative that you fine tune your bow with these or you may not get closer than a couple of inches of field point. These are also not really sturdy enough to stand up to direct hits on bone and you’ll see significant damage to the cutting edge if you hit direct on the shoulder. This may even be enough that you may have to discard the head entirely since you can’t replace the blades.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

G5 Montec Broadhead – $XX.XX / 3

G 5 Outdoors Montec CS Broadhead (3-Pack), 100 Grain

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars from 78 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

The Montec has a classic and clean design that gives both power and penetration.

These broadheads are one of the most popular choices of one piece designs because they don’t fail.

If you want reliability then Montec is a brand that comes up time and time again right along with Muzzy when talking about fixed broadheads.

These have 100% carbon steel blades that are designed to be sharper than the regular Montec heads that delivers absolute precision and a silent design.

  • 1 1/16” cutting diameter
  • 100 grain
  • Penetration Unavailable
  • 100g

Pros:

The problem with replaceable blades is that they will continue to cost you money, especially if you want to replace them each hunt. The g5 can be resharpened time and time again which means it’s much more economical than these so you get multiple uses out of it as long as your blades are intact. The carbon steel construction is easier to sharpen than standard and will hold an edge better as well; it’s also lighter which makes this head faster.

Cons:

If you nick the blade you have to get a whole new head, so what might appear to be a cheaper alternative to replaceable blades becomes far more costly in the long run. They’re also rather pricey. There’s also the slight issue that they don’t fly like field points despite being a fixed-blade head.

Meade Wilderness Spotting Scope 20-60x80 mm

Conclusion:

When it comes to hunting deer you’ve got two different scenarios to contend with and it’s entirely possible you’ll need a combination of fixed and mechanical heads if you’re shooting both ground and tree stand shots.

If you want an overall winner then the Bloodrunner works well because it allows for both scenarios since you’ve got the fixed head that helps it fly faster over open distance and the expandable blades to help with deflection from harder angles.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

To Top