What Is the Best Carbon Arrow in 2017?

1Are you one of those bowhunters that race to buy a bunch of arrows every season – if you are, you may be surprised to learn you are only deceiving yourself. What is the best carbon arrow, we are here to help you find out. First shooting with the right arrow not only improves your accuracy but also makes you successful in the field.

If you want the best performance out of your compound bow, you need the best carbon arrows for your bow setup. Having an incorrectly sized or badly constructed arrow is not going to fly steadily and presents a safety hazard. When partaking in archery you need to consider a number of methodological considerations when selecting the best arrows.

Click here for the Top Carbon Arrow available in 2016!

Here is a brief comparison table of the top Carbon Arrows (article continues below):

Top Carbon Arrows Comparison table

Best Carbon ArrowDraw WeightPriceRating

The Beman ICS Bowhunter Arrow

The Beman ICS Bowhunter Arrow

Click here for price!
5 out of 5 Stars

Click here to read from 5 customer reviews!


The Carbon Express Maxima Red Arrow

The Carbon Express Maxima Red Arrow
40-81 lbs$

Click here for price!
4.5 out of 5 Stars

Click here to read from 67 customer reviews!


The Carbon Express Maxima Blue Streak

The Carbon Express Maxima Blue Streak

Click here for price!
4.4 out of 5 Stars

Click here to read from 16 customer reviews!


The Carbon Express PileDriver Arrow

The Carbon Express PileDriver Arrow

Click here for price!
4.1 out of 5 Stars

Click here to read from 23 customer reviews!


The Gold Tip XT Hunter 5575 Carbon Arrows

The Gold Tip XT Hunter 5575 Carbon Arrows
55-75 lbs $$

Click here for price!
0 Ratings

Click here to read from customer reviews!


You need to consider the following:

  • That it has a proper spine,
  • It is FOC balanced,
  • Has the correct weight,
  • The straightness of the arrow,
  • The Fletching material the arrows made from,
  • The Fletching angle, and
  • The arrow length

Our Selection of the Best Carbon Arrows

The most popular arrows are carbon and many archers use it today. They have tolerance from 0.001 to 0.006-inches and the straighter they are the more expensive they become. That is why they are the best as each one is measured carefully when they come off their production line. Each one separated into different classes all based on how straight they are. The premium ones fall into the 0.001-0.002-inch range, the mid-range ones are within the 0.003-0.004-inches range and your standard ones are 0.005-0.006-inches.

The Gold Tip XT Hunter 5575 Carbon Arrow

Gold Tip XT Hunter 5575/400 Carbon Arrows w/Blazer Vanes Rain Wraps 1Dz.

No customer review available yet. Click the image for prices and be the first to review this item!

The Gold Tip XT Hunter 5575 is one of the best carbon arrows and a number one seller. For bowhunters, this one is the preferred arrows as it is tough and one of the most reliable bow hunting arrows that withstand any training sessions during hunting season.

The carbon arrow has a grain weight of 8.2-inches and a tolerance of +/- 2 grain in a pack of dozen arrows. The manufacturer, hand sorted these arrows and inspected it with a laser to a shaft tolerance of +- 0.003-inches. They are pre-fletched and have a 2-inch Blazer vane all you need to do is to cut the shaft down to the length you need when shooting.

You receive epoxy inserts to use after cutting the shaft and there are many positive reviews online when using these arrows.

Quality Features:

  • You can buy the Gold Tip XT Hunter carbon arrows in a pack of a dozen and it has Blazer Vanes Mossy Oak Blaze Wraps,
  • Shoots at a 55 – 75 lb range,
  • The deflections 8.2 GPI w/.400,
  • They are available in many different colors and includes pathfinder 7-inch wraps,
  • They have a 360° rotating nock with aluminum inserts and 32-inches long.

Pros: the best carbon arrows you can use for hunting, it has an exceptional tolerance, and you can buy them in a pack of 12

Cons: they are a bit on the expensive side as their straightness is +- 0.003/1000


The Carbon Express Maxima Red Arrow

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars from 60 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

The Carbon Express Maxima Red is another popular arrow used by many hunters. It has a state of the art design for improved Broadhead accuracy and performance. The reason for this is that these arrows have stiff ends with in-flight flexing.

It has a dynamic spine that controls only two spine sizes to meet your draw weight from 40-81 pounds. The manufacturer has laser measured the straightness of these arrows and sorted them according to the tolerance zone of +- 0.0025-inches.

Some of the other nice characteristics of these arrows are the BullDog collars, the Blazer vanes, and the LAUNCHPAD nocks. They can handle wear and tear as the collars shield the nock. It is a premium arrow and customers are pleased with this product as they get quality and consistency in weight when used.

Eminent Features:

  • The Carbon Express arrows have LAUNCHPAD Precision Nocks, fletched Blazer Vanes, and BullDog Nock Collars and the vane colors vary,
  • Has a high-tech construction of carbon material with a dynamic spine to make the Broadheads fly better and more consistent when you shoot them,
  • The carbon arrows are laser checked for its straightness to an incredible 1/10,000-inches,
  • This is a 250-size 8 arrow with an 8.11-GPI and has a 0.417-inch spine and its diameter is 0.295-inches, and
  • You can buy them in packs of 6 with a black finish and sorted according to the weight and spine

Pros: the arrows present you with a straight shot at all times, when shot they are fast and straight, it packs a lot of power, they are excellent arrows for hunting

Cons: They are not cheap but what can you expect they are made of carbon


The Carbon Express Maxima Blue Streak

12 - Pk. Carbon Express Blue Streak Shafts

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars from 16 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

If you are looking for the lightest arrow made with the highest speed and accuracy, you need to get yourself the Carbon Express Maxima Blue Streak.

The shafts made from Diamond Weave carbon material and cross-weaved. This form of style creates a stiffer arrow that has immense spine consistency. The rest of the arrows made with high-quality material as well. Right out of the box the arrow has a straightness lenience of +-0.0025-inches and weighs +-1 grain.

It comes included with a LAUNCHPAD nock and the BullDog collar to protect the ends and pre-fletched with white and blue Blazer vanes.

Renowned Features:

  • These are the best carbon arrows and you can buy them in packs of 12,
  • They are lightweight and give you accuracy with speed when shot,
  • It has Diamond Weave technology used in the spine with Dual Spine Weight Forward technology for fast recovery and guidance,
  • For extra strength, it has a BullDog nock collar,
  • The maximum straightness of the arrow is +-0.0025-inches with a weight of +- 1.0 grain,
  • You can buy the Carbon Express Maxima in different sizes 150, 250, or 350, and
  • These arrows are not fletched

Pros: you can buy them in three different sizes; they give you loads of accuracy and speed, for fast recovery, these are the best,

Cons: not fletched as in the image and a bit on the costly side


The Beman ICS Bowhunter Arrows

1 Dozen Beman ICS Bowhunter Shafts

Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars from 5 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

The Beman ICS Bowhunter arrow is a mid-range choice at an affordable price. You can buy them in packs of a dozen for half the price you pay for six premium arrows.

Just because they are cheaper does not mean that they do not perform, you will be surprised. The arrow is 32-inches long and has a pre-installed yellow fluorescent Easton nock and best to cut the shafts according to the length you need.

The shaft straightness is good at +-0.006-inches and still gives you the accuracy you need. Many bowhunters is pleased with this product as it gives them hard hitting performance and accuracy.

Prominent Features:

  • The Beman ICS Bowhunter arrow is made from durable ICS C2 carbon making them perfectly balanced for speed,
  • The arrow has a straightness of +-0.006-inches and weighs +- 2.0 grains with a direct fit Super nock,
  • Included you receive the CB inserts and does not come with Fletching while there are others available that do come with Fletching, and
  • You can buy them in a pack of dozen at an affordable price.

Pros: affordably priced, when used they give you perfect stability with a great speed compared to the more premium arrows

Cons: not much complaint related to the product and one cannot compare them to the more expensive carbon arrows


The Carbon Express PileDriver Arrow

Carbon Express PileDriver Hunter Fletched BuffTuff Carbon Arrows

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars from 20 customers. Click the image for prices and reviews!

This is one of the heaviest arrows made by Carbon Express. The Carbon Express PileDriver is made for the hunter who wants to carry the arrow force to impact targets at a long-range. Here the manufacturer has used Weight Forward technology for a tight grouping.

You need to remember when buying these carbon arrows that you will have to cut the shaft to length and glue on the inserts. The arrows have a durable finish of Mossy Oak Brush that makes up a ⅔ radius of the shaft with a bright yellow Assault vane of 2-inches.

Overall, these arrows received the best carbon arrow reviews online when it comes to feedback from clients who have bought the product.

Outstanding Features:

  • These arrows come fletched with Assault Vanes measuring 2-inches,
  • Designed with LAUNCHPAD Precision Nocks and for the protecting the arrow it has BullDog Nock Collars,
  • Designed with Weight Forward technology, making them great when downrange for accuracy in a Broadhead,
  • For straightness, Carbon Express uses a laser and measures +- 0.0005-inches with a size of 250,
  • It has 10.4-Genuine Progress Indication and the spine measures 0.402-inches with a diameter of 0.302-inches, and
  • You can buy them in a 6-pack with camouflaged pattern shafts sorted according to weight

Pros: the arrows group extremely well, you can cut them down to size, when used they shoot consistently

Cons: Some minor complaints that you cannot use them multiple Broadheads


The Basics of a Carbon Arrow

Here are some basics of a carbon arrow:

  • The foundation of the arrow is the shaft (the long hollow tube made from carbon or aluminum composite),
  • The rear is known as a nock and normally a piece of molded plastic,
  • In the front section you find a sleeve either made of aluminum or plastic called the insert and screws onto the tip, and
  • The last section of the arrows the Fletching and normally consists of colorful shaped soft plastic known as the vanes or feathers.

The Normal Measurements of an Arrow

The normal Archery Manufacturers Organization (AMO) when measuring arrows you find in the distance between the base of nock groove to the end of the arrow and does not include the tip. If you need to buy replacements for your arrow make sure that you measure it according to the AMO standards.

The Different Types of Arrows

  1. Wood Arrows – for century’s people have used wood-shafted arrows, however, if you are a traditional longbow archer for hunting you will not shoot with them. They are slower and heavier to shoot. They are not suitable for hunting, as it requires a tight tolerance when using a compound bow.
  2. Aluminum arrows – this has been the arrow shaft of choice with bow archery. It is an affordable, strong, and lightweight arrow. It is heavier than the carbon arrow, although most hunters prefer the heavier aluminum shafts as it transfers the energy more efficiently.
  3. The carbon arrow – in the 1990s, it gained popularity and the most bowhunters use these arrows. They are lighter and hold a tight tolerance that results in a high-speed with increased accuracy and penetration.

What Is The Difference Between the Carbon Express Maxima Blue and Red

Both of these carbon arrows are the best for hunting. However, when looking closer at the specs there is not that much of a difference between them.

The main difference is how Carbon Express has constructed the shafts as the Maxima Blue Streak has Weight Forward making it a lighter arrow. While the design of the Maxima Red end is stiffer and helps to control the forceful spine.

If you want added weight with penetrating power, the Maxima Red arrows are the ones you need to use while the Maxima Blue Streaks is a faster arrow.

Final Thoughts

We hope that our carbon arrow reviews help you to make the best decision when it comes to buying your carbon arrows. As you can see, carbon arrows are not cheap, but they are the best when it comes to hunting. They give you speed, accuracy, and penetrating power to take out your target with ease. All of these carbon arrows received excellent feedback online, but as with any product, you do have some negative remarks, as nothing is perfect.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

To Top